What is wrong with the wide receivers? So many disappointing week one performances!
With week 1 of the NFL season in the books, fantasy managers everywhere are celebrating a win or agonizing over a tough loss. But there is little time to revel or dwell as owners must scour the waiver wire for that extra bit of help, stream a defense or kicker, or fill roster holes due to injury. Still others are looking for that potential trade partner who won’t shoot them down. If you are among the 1-0 teams out there, congratulations on starting the season strong. To everyone else I say, keep your wits about you and make good choices. This week, the Philly Special League saw two come from behind victories, one blowout, and a high-scoring matchup that wasn’t decided until the clock hit zero on Monday Night Football. I’m excited for this season!
While the NFL started out with a bang (or a Hawk Tuah?) on Thursday between the Eagles and Cowboys, fantasy owners started out the week with some disappointment. Sure, Saquan did his thing for the Jawns, and Javonte Williams did even better – on the waiver wire in this league. Is that because we all have really good running backs or because everyone in this league hates the Cowboys? Maybe both, but I have a strict “No Dallas Cowboys players on my fantasy roster policy.” Even Goedert has a solid fantasy performance. But the disappointment I mentioned came from the wide receivers. You could argue that CeeDee Lamb had a good fantasy performance, eclipsing 100 yards and earning fantasy owners 18 points. But when you factor in the dropped passes that could have not only given him substantially more fantasy points, but could also have won the game for the Cowboys, this wasn’t a good day for the number 3 ranked fantasy WR. In fact, both Lamb and A.J. Brown combined for under 20 fantasy points and no touchdowns – a frustrating start for owners of these top-ten receivers.
The WR struggles continued into Friday as Xavier Worthy left the game before recording a catch, leaving the Lion Den to stare at 0.0 until Sunday. And then Sunday brought more of the same. Chase with 4.6 and St. Brown with 8.5, two more receivers in the top ten both failed to reach 10 fantasy points. Until Jefferson scored on Monday night, Thomas Jr, was the only top-ten WR to score a touchdown – and it was a rushing TD – and he only totaled 9 fantasy points. Out of the top-20 ranked WRs, based on ESPN’s PPR League Cheat Sheet, there were only four TDs scored. Not a great way to start the fantasy season for some owners out there. The top four scoring WRs of week one had been ranked no higher than 24, with the lowest ranked at 83. That means a lot of points were left on the bench or on the waiver wire, both of which are frustrating for fantasy managers. Let’s take a look at our league matchups from this week.

Uncle Cunningham vs Jacque’s Lion Den
Uncle Cunningham had a great draft and what looked to be a solid team. His squad looked poised to take down the Lion Den in week one especially after Worthy’s early exit on Friday. Despite Chase’s lack of production, Uncle Cunningham saw solid performances from his QB, Jayden Daniels, RBs, FLEX, and TE, but not enough to match the initially very high projected score for his team. The Lion Den started off slow, with the first of her points coming from the afternoon contests. Nacua got this going with a nice performance as one of only two top-20 receivers to exceed 20 fantasy points, though he failed to score and CMC posted a solid 23.2 points while also staying healthy – that’s a win in and of itself! The four Lions players on her roster then seemed to stall any momentum by combining for 23.9 points, leaving Jacque in a 93.72 – 70.2 deficit going into Sunday Night Football. Well, we all know what happened here, right? Josh Allen did Josh Allen things, going off for 38.76 fantasy points and justifying the decision to draft him first overall (at least for this week) while Kincaid’s 14.8 added to the total, turning this into a blowout as Uncle Cunningham could only watch the Lion Den run up the score on their way to a week one victory.

Cheeseheads of Northern WI vs OKC Krakhawkiners
Cheeseheads of Northern WI faced off against the OKC Krakhawkiners. Their roster projections were evenly matched to start, but that quickly got thrown out the window as Cheeseheads jumped out to an early lead on Thursday thanks to Jalen Hurts, and the team never looked back. OKC’s WRs and FLEX only totaled 19.7 between them, while Cheeseheads only had two players in single digits, with Collins and Engram. But while even the Cheeseheads strong roster was not immune to the poor WR trend in week one, the consistent performances across the board, aided by 26 points from his defense and kicker, led Shawn to a victory that was never in doubt.

FIITHY FLII FLIX vs Jawns
FIIthy FLII FLIX faced off against Jawns in a matchup of the last placed finisher from 2024 against the unproven newcomer. This was another matchup that saw evenly matched rosters in the early projections, but Jawns jumped out to a big early lead on the strength of performances by Mahomes and Barkley. Sunday saw the matchup get close, with FFF trying to claw their way into it, and went into Sunday Night Football with Jawns leading 97.72-78.64. And then there was Derrick Henry. The same Derrick Henry who fell to round 3 of the draft proceeded to run all over Buffalo to give FFF 29.2 fantasy points and the lead while the Ravens defense set Jawns back seven points. Jawns’ Hockenson and Santos were no match for FFF’s Jefferson, and the come from behind win was secured on Monday night.

Hurts Donut vs Juliano Joneses
Our last matchup was a rematch of last year’s championship game between my Hurts Donut squad (named Fat Batman last season in honor of Jason Kelce) and the Juliano Joneses. Julian’s team sputtered from the start, giving him only 3.8 points between Brown and the Eagles defense to start the week. My offense started on Friday night with Hampton, who also stumbled out the gate with 8.1 points, leaving us with a pedestrian 8.1 – 12.8 total after Dicker gave the Joneses 9 points. Things heated up on Sunday. Murray, Robinson, Achane, and Bowers did what I had hoped and set me up with solid fantasy performances all around. Here is where I started to regret trading away Herbert for Murray before the first game as I looked at his 27.92 fantasy points sitting on the Jawns bench. I should also mention here a bad habit I have, which is leaving rookie talent on the bench. Last year, I drafted Worthy and left him on the bench week one. “Let’s see how he does,” I said and he scored 20.8 that week. This year, I drafted Egbuka and did the same thing. He scored 23.6 on my bench.
Anyway, I felt better while watching the Joneses struggle with Harvey, Brown, and Higgins all staying in single-digits while LaPorta and Kyren Williams each put up 13.9. Even with St. Brown and Adams giving me only 8.5 and 9.1 points respectively, I was still sitting at 100.22 – 54.8 going into Sunday Night Football feeling pretty good. I should probably mention here that I had the Ravens kicker and Vikings defense remaining while the Joneses had none other than Lamar Jackson and Zay Flowers… anyone else in this position this week? Then you know how I felt watching Julian’s score go up and up and up with each pass – with each QB run – with each catch. 57.46 points between Jackson and Flowers erased every bit of the score deficit and would have given him the lead if not for the 13 points scored by Loop.
But it wasn’t over. I still had the Vikings defense to go and, as anyone who has played fantasy football knows (and how the Jawns knows just this week), your defense can give you negative points. Have any of you dropped or benched your defense in a situation like this? I was holding on for dear life to a 113.22 – 112.26 lead – less than a point! The thought had crossed my mind but I dismissed it and let things play out on Monday Night. Normally I would not care that the Vikings defense could not stop the Bears, could not sack Caleb Williams, and could not tackle to save their lives. But I cared deeply this week. Every missed tackle. Every missed sack. Every yard and every point saw those initial 10 points given to my defense get whittled down further and further until I was sure I was going to lose. Then the Vikings scored, and their defense had new life. I relaxed a little until the Vikings took the lead, knowing that could lead to more points and yards as Chicago pushed to tie or win the game. In the end, I held on for a slim 117.22 – 112.26 victory. This was the highest scoring game of the week and the closest and I couldn’t have asked for a more exciting ending to the week.

How did the week go from your perspective? What surprised you? What frustrated you?

Go Birds!







